What Does Eggnog Taste Like? The Ultimate Guide!

What Does Eggnog Taste Like? 

What Does Eggnog Taste Like? 

The article provides a description of eggnog’s flavor, how it should be used, and it also answers the question you are curious to know: What does eggnog taste like? Read on if you are interested.

Well, nothing can signal the beginning of the festive season like seeing eggnog appear on the shelves at the local supermarket.

This drink is associated with winter holiday celebrations and with good reason! The rich and soothing drink is a great choice for a simple sip or transformed into a festive punch.

There are many possibilities. You might have seen bowls of eggnog at celebrations or even spotted some nog inside the fridge but you’ve never decided to give the drink a go.

It could be a bit unsettling if you’re not certain the ingredients or how it’s made or even what you’ll taste like.

So, what does eggnog taste like? Eggnog is usually described as tasting like sweet, creamy, and rich melting ice cream that is seasoned with nutmeg, cinnamon, and clove. There are other flavors like the addition of vanilla or other alcohols.

Learn more about what eggnog actually is, how it’s created, the best liquors to drink in an eggnog drink, and how you can create your own traditional or dairy-free versions by making yourself at home.

What Is Eggnog?

It’s possible that you’re like me, and have an equivocal idea of eggnog, but you don’t really know what ingredients are in it or what it’s made of.

In the past, it was referred to as milk punch, or an egg-milk punch when spirits or alcohol are added. Its originated in the earlier medieval Britain and comes from “posset”–a similar drink to a milky ale.

In the early 1200s, monks were drinking possets made of eggs, milk and figs. This could be more similar to what we call “eggnog”. But, modern eggnogs have changed with regard to ingredients and preparation techniques.

Modern eggnog is typically composed of cream, milk sugar, egg whites that have been whipped as well as egg yolks.

A quick whipping of the whites with a whisk gives the eggnog its delicate texture, while mixing into the egg yolks gives depth to the cream and milk for a truly luxurious holiday drink.

Certain versions may also include cinnamon, vanilla or nutmeg. Other versions may also include different alcohols, based on the brand and the personal preference of those who make your own.

What Does Eggnog Taste Like?

Eggnog is a unique taste that isn’t exactly the like any other available.

It is made up of the same ingredients as the ice cream, but it isn’t processed and frozen in similarly. A few people refer to eggnog as a drink made of sweet, spicy melted Ice cream.

The spiced flavor is due to the spice blend to cinnamon, nutsmeg and clove, but not all brands will contain any or all of these spices.

The overall flavor is sweet due to the sugar added to it. If you’re not a fan of spice, eggnog may not be the beverage for you.

It’s thick smooth, rich, and smooth due to the thick creamy cream, the whole milk eggs, and yolks of an egg.

Egg whites add some lightness, but overall, the texture is rich and creamy. If you’re a fan of sweet, rich desserts or drinks, then eggnog will satisfy all your needs.

The overall flavor of eggnog is an incredibly rich, creamy frozen ice cream that has the spiced undertones of clove, cinnamon and the spice of nutmeg. It’s possible to reduce the creamy taste by adding some of your preferred alcohol like cognac, rum, brandy or whiskey.

What’s The Difference Between Store-bought And Homemade Eggnog?

In the case of the comparison between homemade and store-bought eggnog, there will be people who will remain in one side and those who are in the opposite. Both have an appropriate place at the table during the holidays because they have different advantages.

If you’re looking for consistency, eggnog that is available in the store is the way to go.

The companies that produce eggnog have the production process down to a scientific process, and you’ll not be disappointed once you get a carton of creamy and rich eggnog from the brand you love.

Brands that are sold in stores will differ slightly between different brands as they each come with their own production and recipe styles. However, if you take a look, I’m confident that you’ll discover a brand that will suit your taste to a T.

When you make homemade eggnog, it could be slightly richer since you’re using all-natural ingredients and are not trying to make money out of your nog.

The brands you buy at the store may be slightly diluted or might make use of skim or regular dairy instead of full milk, which means that homemade milk may be thicker.

You are also able to alter the spice and flavor levels to suit your taste since you have control of the entire process from beginning to end.

If you’d like sweeter nog, increase the sugar. If you’re looking to add more spice, add cinnamon, nutmeg or clove. If you’re a lover of vanilla, you can add some vanilla into the mix.

The down side is that it requires more effort to whip your eggs, boil the milk, then prepare your own nog as opposed to opening the carton and just start enjoying it immediately.

If you’re looking to get an ideal mix of the two possibilities, you could make your own eggnog by adding additional ingredients, more cream, more sweetener an alcohol shot or some vanilla.

Don’t be afraid of making your own nog that you bought from the grocery store you like.

Does Eggnog taste like Bubblegum?

The answer can both be yeh and nay.

Eggnog is akin to bubblegum for certain people, but for the majority of people, it’s not. Some people believe it tastes like bubblegum whole milk. Eggnog may taste similar to bubblegum because of the ingredients.

The drink is made of eggs, sugar, milk alcohol, nutmeg or cinnamon. It is also possible to detect bubblegum flavor in other alcohol mix-ups.

How to Make Eggnog Taste Better?

If you’re looking to add some spice and flavor to your eggnog drink, here are some ideas to consider:

It is possible to add nutmeg in your eggnog. Find some fresh nutmeg, and sprinkle it on the top of your cup of eggnog. You’ll be amazed by the difference it can make.

Are you aware of something more delicious than spice? Rum with spices! If you’re looking to try something different and interesting try splashing a bit of spiced rum in the glass of bland eggnog.

A bizarre, yet delicious mix is eggnog with pumpkin puree. It may sound unappealing, but it enhances the eggnog flavor more delicious!

Include some bittersweet chocolate in your eggnog. Eggnog is already a milk-based beverage and adding milk won’t have any effect. However, adding a few ounces of bittersweet chocolate over your eggnog is a great option for rich taste.

The easiest and simplest method to enhance the flavor of your eggnog is by adding some cinnamon. Sprinkle some ground cinnamon over your eggnog. It will make the eggnog taste better!

If you’re looking for something that’s sweet and alcoholic simultaneously you can mix whip cream vodka into your eggnog. The vodka provides a sweet and creamy flavor to the eggnog and adds a flavor that is even more delicious.

You can also include cognac in your eggnog. If you’d like to feel like a home-cooked meal, simply mix your eggnog with cognac in the jug before serving.

Watch this video that tells how to make eggnog at home:

How to Serve Eggnog?

Eggnog can be served in various ways according to your preference and your taste.

Eggnog can be served either with alcohol or served with heavy or light cream or even some spices. It is possible to include whiskey, rum or brandy to your eggnog in order to add a more festive holiday vibe.

It is also possible to bake eggnog-based cakes and eggnog pies.

Although eggnog usually contains alcohol but you can also serve it with a non-alcoholic option. Non-alcoholic versions are widely sold at supermarkets.

All in every case, it is possible to find many eggnog recipes.

You can also add heavy cream to give your eggnog a rich consistency. It is also possible to top the lighter eggnogs with whipped cream. Certain eggnog drinks only require yolks, whereas others need lots of eggs.

You can also add other ingredients like cinnamon and cloves.

A recipe from 1862 at the most involves filling the shaker of a cocktail quarter full of ice, then by adding milk to one-third of the shake. Then, you add one tablespoon of water, and sugar. After that, add a glass of brandy and a second wineglass of Rum. Shake the cocktail and strain it before serving it with the nutmeg shavings.

In addition, your eggnog could include warming alcohol such as whiskey or brandy.

It is possible to mix eggnog with multiple spirits. Better yet, mix eggnog with vanilla or apricot-infused alcohol.

Eggnog can be added in your cup of coffee. It is also possible to mix eggnog into milkshakes or frozen ice cream. Serve eggnog with desserts and other pastries. It is also possible to bake cookies or cheesecake.

Do you Drink Eggnog Hot or Cold?

It is possible to drink eggnog cold or hot. It is more popular that you drink the beverage cold however, a majority of people like it warm.

You can drink the drink warm by adding an ounce of brandy or dark rum, and heating it up in the microwave.

It is even more delicious in the event that you mix it by adding 2percent milk.

To warm your eggnog, put it into a microwave-safe cup and then microwave it in thirty second intervals until it’s warm enough or hot enough for you. The time needed to cook is dependent on the strength of your microwave and the temperature you prefer.

Warm eggnog is a great match for chocolate cake and tastes delicious on cold evenings.

The most traditional and traditional method of serving eggnog is drinking it chilled. It requires no additional preparation. It’s all you have to do is put your eggnog in the glass or mug.

It is great when baked goods that are made with milk or cream.

How Do You Make Eggnog?

If you’re not keen to wait until eggnog is on the shelves, or would like to have a go in creating your own version, the process is an easy process when you know what to do.

It will require some ingredients and a little determination, yet the final product will be quite an amazing eggnog that supermarket brands can’t match.

Ingredients

  • 4 eggs, yolks separated and whites in separate bowls
  • 1/3 cup sugar plus 1 tablespoon of sugar separated
  • Two cups of milk that is whole
  • 1 cup heavy cream

Optional ingredients

  • 1 teaspoon vanilla
  • 1/2 teaspoon of cinnamon
  • 1/2 teaspoon freshly grated 1 teaspoon fresh grated
  • 2 ounces cognac, bourbon or whiskey.

Directions

In a bowl small enough, beat eggs yolks until their color becomes lighter.

When the yolks have changed color, mix in 12 cup of sugar, then put aside.

Set a pot on moderate heat. Mix the entire liquid, including heavy cream cinnamon, vanilla and Nutmeg.

Bring the mixture slowly to a low simmer, stirring it frequently. Be careful not to allow it to get too hot as it could ignite and cause burning to the milk.

Take the milk mixture off the heat and take about 1 tablespoon. Pour the mixture into a bowl. Slowly mix mixture into egg yolks. Repeat two more times.

After eggs have been mixed, add them to the milk mixture, then return it to the stove and bring it to a simmer, with a stirring. If you’ve got thermometer, heat it up to 160 degrees F.

Once the mixture is warmed, remove the mix from the stove and transfer it to an empty bowl. Then, place the mix in the refrigerator.

With a handheld or stand mixer, begin whipping the egg whites to stiff white peaks. While whipping them, gradually add the remaining sugar tablespoon to the mixture.

After the milk mixture is become cool and cooled, gently whisk the egg whites with the milk mixture. Pour in your preferred drink and enjoy.

Can You Add Alcohol To Eggnog?

Absolutely, you can mix alcohol into eggnog to create an alcoholic holiday drink that is rich and delicious.

A lot of eggnog enthusiasts prefer dark, stronger spirits as they are able to break through all the sweetness of drink. The most popular eggsnog-related ingredients are:

Brandy: It is an alcohol created by distilling wine. It is among the most popular ingredients to an eggnog beverage.

Cognac: it is actually a form of brandy made of double-distilled wine. It is made in a copper pan. A lot of people recommend mixing cognac and rum to make the perfect eggnog cocktail for Christmas.

Rum: dark, spiced Rum is particularly good because it enhances the eggnog’s flavor and texture.

Whiskey: it is always a classic but you may not be able to drink one that is too smokey or sweet. Consider a blend of Scottish whiskey or one that is an Irish whiskey.

Bourbon: a whiskey based on corn that is distilled in America It is perfect addition to delicious eggnog cocktail that is boozy.

It’s clear that there’s plenty of spirits to try. You don’t have to limit yourself to one brand. You are free to be inventive and play with different various combinations of spirits until you can find the one that soothes your insides and will make your taste buds sing.

It is possible to try eggnog plain before trying cups made with the various spirits (or mixtures with spirits!) added to the mix , so you can determine which one is your most loved festive drink.

Are There Dairy Free Versions Of Eggnog?

Although it may seem like dairy and cream is a standard element of eggnog many people are choosing to be dairy-free due to various reasons.

Luckily for them all, a few companies have stepped up the challenge to develop delightful dairy-free products.

There are a variety of brands that available that makes their eggnog with plants-based milk sources like almond, soy, coconut and more.

One of the strongest and delicious brands on the market is from So Delicious Coconut milk Holiday Nog.

It’s a delicious, creamy coconut nog. It’s also egg-free which means it’s vegan- friendly. While you’re not yet able to see eggnog products on shelves however, it will be on the shelves in no time.

Other honorable mentions are made for the brands listed below:

Blue Diamond: Blue Diamond Almond Breeze Almond Milk Nog – this brand is made from almond milk. It’s a dense option that is similar to the traditional eggnog taste.

Silk Nog Original: – The silk brand is generally excellent with its dairy-free milk alternatives; however, this eggnog may be a bit smaller than alternatives available. It has a pleasant flavor, and if the nog to be less thick it could be the perfect choice for you.

 Califia Farms AlmondMilk Holiday Nog – it is another dairy-free eggnog. This one is rather thin and does not have the same eggnog taste; however, it’s a good choice in the event that you’re unable to locate one other brands that are listed above, and you’re really craving the eggnog taste.

Since all of these are vegan, and also dairy-free, they aren’t containing egg yolks or egg whites, which gives eggnog the distinctive texture, richness and creaminess.

If you’re lactose-free, but are not vegan it is possible to make your own version eggnog with macadamia, oat, coconut or almond milk alternatives.

Can You Find Vegan Eggnog?

Many who are lactose-free can prefer veganism, which is why there’s plenty of overlap in the eggnogs made without dairy that we have listed above.

Each one is also vegan because they utilize thickeners or emulsifiers to create the thick, eggnog like texture, instead of egg yolks and whites.

If you’re in search of delicious eggnog made from vegan ingredients, test one of these brands:

So Delicious Coconut Milk Holiday Nog

Blue Diamond Almond Breeze Almondmilk Nog

Silk Nog– Original

Califia Holiday Nog- Almond Milk

Wrapping up

What Does Eggnog Taste Like? 

As you can see, there are lots of options in the matter of enjoying the holiday spirit.

You can purchase one at the local grocery store or create your own at home, or try making it vegan or dairy-free or add your preferred alcohol to make a delicious boozy drink or drink chilled glasses straight out of the fridge.

The possibilities are endless, and the taste is distinctive: creamy, rich and sweet. It’s thick, sweet and stuffed with warming spices eggnog is a perfect drink for winter to keep you warm from the inside out.

Eggnog is an excellent drink that you shouldn’t be missing out on during the holiday season. But, make sure that you drink it in moderation.